David Reviews

 "You're not an artist, Peggy. You solve problems." Don Draper.

These scores are compiled from a combination of our in-house rating system and user ratings. Only UK work from the last two years is considered.
 1. Chayse Irvin 89.0%  
 2. Deepa Keshvala 89.0%  
 3. Daniel Landin 88.9%  
 4. Justin Brown 87.8%  
 5. Mauro Chiarello 87.7%  
 6. Kaname Onoyama 87.6%  
 7. James Laxton 87.3%  
 8. Molly Manning Walker 86.9%  
 9. Joost van Gelder 86.5%  
 10. Steve Annis 86.4%  
 11. Luke Jacobs 85.1%  
 12. Lasse Frank 84.9%  
 13. Ben Fordesman 84.8%  
 14. Simon Chaudoir 84.6%  
 15. Jim Jolliffe 84.2%  
 16. Vanessa Whyte 84.2%  
 17. Ray Coates 84.2%  
 18. Jaime Feliu Torres 84.0%  
 19. Alex Barber 84.0%  
 20. Franz Lustig 83.9%  
 21. Sebastian Blenkov 83.8%  
 22. Patrick Meller 83.7%  
 23. Rina Yang 83.6%  
 24. Alex Melman 82.7%  
 25. Ben Smithard 82.4%  

On This Day
(1-25 of 25)

20 Jan 2009
Pfizer is not just protecting its bottom line when it urges us not to buy cloned drugs from the Internet. Apparently such purchases can be a danger to our health as they contain unconventional ingredients (such as rat poison in one extreme case).

"Pack Up Your Troubles"
20 Jan 2014
This promising trail for the BBC's coverage of the centenary of World War I suggests much excellent programming lies ahead. With David Cameron proposing a "celebration" of this year's centenary and seeking to draw parallels with the London Olympics in orer to generate a bit of pre-election feelgood factor, our government is going to do what it can to avoid a thoughtful reflection provoked by this most poignant of anniversaries.

"A New Image"
20 Jan 2014
Well, now: this looks like fun. A brilliantly put-together selection of excerpts suggest up-coming comedy-drama Babylon really is must-see TV. Directed by Danny Boyle and coming "from the creators of Peep Show and Fresh Meat" this fast-paced trail is bound to appeal to anyone who likes their humour a bit edgy. Add Paterson Joseph, Jonny Sweet and James Nesbitt into the mix and you've got something that could cause quite a stir.

St John Ambulance
"Nursery Rhymes"
2 mins 17s
20 Jan 2016
The DAVID household has been intending to take up first aid lessons ever since an incident two years ago involving the near-tragic mis-swallowing of a spring roll, which has now gone down in family lore. This resolve has been strengthened on watching the new spot for the St John Ambulance in which famous nursery characters create a mnemonic song to aid CPR on babies.

"Tough Love, Soft Love"
20 Jan 2016
If you're looking for sympathy on account of your winter cough, good luck finding it from John C McGinley. Well, sort of - it depends which side of the bed you're looking at. Halls assign their menthol and honey variants to two very different spokespeople - both played with gusto by the 'Scrubs' and 'Platoon' actor.

"Sausage Twist"
20 Jan 2016
Hats off to BOLD's Zach Math for going the extra mile with Mike Crowe and Rob Messeter's promising script to create a really funny flight of fantasy. As in the previous ad, someone cooking a fairly pedestrian meal wonders what they can do to make it more exciting and starts day-dreaming. In this execution, a mum starts thinking about eating in the great outdoors... sausages cooked over a naked flame and the whole family ready to enjoy the sense of well-being you get from fresh air and wild possibilities.

"Speak Up"
20 Jan 2004
This ad provides a powerful portrayal of an abusive parent, and manages to do so without actually showing her on screen. The effect is seen clearly on the face of a boy who doesn't speak a word throughout. His silence allows viewers to focus on the sharp words coming from his mother, cleverly illustrating the idea that talking would help it to stop.

Peugeot 407
"Men Are Back"
20 Jan 2006
It's a Woman's World according to this ad for the new Peugeot 407 Coupé which is shown catching the attention of all the women in this commercial. Plainly men have been banished as we see all the macho jobs such as construction workers and fire fighters have been taken by women.

Virgin Atlantic
20 Jan 2008
It's rare these days for a commercial to successfully describe a problem and then successfully describe a solution to it. But that's exactly what happens here as a rather wan-looking John Hannah talks about the preciousness of time and then explains what Virgin Atlantic has done to help.

20 Jan 2009
A re-edit of a commercial from last year has people holding placards bouncing up towards the camera before the car itself does the same. The black background brings emphasis to proceedings, improving on what was already a strong idea.

Cadbury Crème Eggs
"Egg Slicer"
20 Jan 2009
This year's cruelty commences with a brilliant leap onto some kitchen scales which act as a trampoline enabling the suicidal chocolate egg to dive through an egg slicer and reducing itself to slices of even thickness.

20 Jan 2009
This American ad has more than a little in common with last year's Hovis ad as it attempts to show the role played by Pepsi across the generations. This slightly veers towards an unwise suggestion that Pepsi played a role in the events it depicts.

Chemistry Ireland
"Mad Men Sponsorship"
20 Jan 2010
This series of bumpers bracketing the broadcasts of Mad Men in the Irish Republic do something that's very unusual in advertising... they advertise an advertising agency. But it's an excellent idea... all the more so because it's been pulled off with such aplomb.

Cyber Mentors
"Cyber Bully"
20 Jan 2010
A teenage girl's sense of alienation and isolation is illustrated through a brutal act of self harm in this hard-hitting film warning about the dangers of cyber bullying. There appears to be no limits to Graham Fink's appetite for shock tactics.

The British Family
"The British Family"
20 Jan 2010
The BBC is launching an ambitious examination of the British family and this trail uses a combination of effects to suggest that our homes are a repository of considerable knowledge about us as we pass through them on our journey through life.

"Next Top Model Sponsorship"
20 Jan 2010
The idea that supermodels are catty is rendered literal in this series of bumpers advertising ASOS's sponsorship of America's Next Top Model. They're good fun but cats have English accents, don't they?

20 Jan 2010
A reprise of a technique which has been used for Toyota before shows people unveiling a skin from the car to reveal another beneath. At the end of the journey, the driver is able to pull the entire car away before it can be given a ticket by a traffic warden. If only.

BBC Knowledge
"Eat Up Brain"
20 Jan 2010
This impressive animated ad for BBC Knowledge suggests that it's regretful that we forget 80% of what we learn in any given day. But is it? In reality, we'd be driven insane by retaining all of the data we encounter but it provides a neat basis for a charming commercial.

"Bring It On"
20 Jan 2011
A series of people are ready to face extraordinary challenges after downing a small bottle of the advertised gloop. It appears to have the same property as a gallon of lager to judge by these peoples' displays of ostentatious courageousness.

Visit Scotland
20 Jan 2013
As part of the "Year of Natural Scotland" campaign, this ad provides an excellent portrait of what the country has to offer by way of landscapes and outdoor activities. Impressive scenery, wildlife, and shots of the northern lights are combined with white water rafting, mountain biking and more to communicate that there's a diverse choice to be enjoyed.

Visit Scotland
20 Jan 2013
This does a nice job of conveying what people want from a trip to Scotland, taking in everything from the Orkney's mysterious standing stones to full-on kilt-wearing, castle-based entertainment. It's promoting the "Year of Natural Scotland", so it's not clear how theatre plays a part in that, but to say that's a flaw would just be pedantry.

"Isn't This Life Enough?"
20 Jan 2014
Scottish band Admiral Fallow have adapted their own song Isn't This World Enough? for this feel-good ad for an American power company. It's a heart-warming collage of imagery and successfully conveys the idea that the reliable and easily-controlled energy provided by PPL is something that provides comfort to its customers.

Six Nations
20 Jan 2014
The annual Six Nations rugby tournament is almost upon us and - as usual - the BBC has put together an impressive trail to trumpet its advent. Differently accented-voices from these islands (but alas none from France or Italy) extol the virtues of "rugby's greatest championship*"
* Apart from any involving New Zealand, Australia and South Africa, obvs.

20 Jan 2014
Mel Giedroyc is really getting into her stride as the voice of Asda. Sounding charming, quirky and spontaneous, she explains - with the help of a few scarecrows - how Green Supermarket could save you 10% on your shopping bills. We'd love to have seen the producer's face when they realised they were going to need the services of a crow wrangler for this job.

Sky Go
"Bear Grylls"
20 Jan 2014
"Mirror, mirror on the the wall... who's the gamest of them all?" Joanna Lumley, of course. The veteran actress parks her dignity at the door once again and throws herself whole-heartedly into playing a version of herself who cannot live without Sky's entertaining output. They are really getting their money's worth.

On This Day
(1-25 of 25)

David Reviews - Lovely Lenzie Ltd, Woodbourne House, Seven Sisters, Lenzie, G66 3AW. Telephone: +44 141 776 7766. Editor: Jason Stone.