David Reviews

 "You're not an artist, Peggy. You solve problems." Don Draper.

THE JOHN LEWIS CHRISTMAS ADS - RANKED
17 November 2019

There's no question that the John Lewis Christmas commercial is the most hyped piece of advertising of the year, and now that it's landed, let's take the opportunity to compare its performance with previous years.

Our ratings system has its flaws, but that's no reason to disregard its results, and so we present all nine Christmas ads since 'The Long Wait' reinvented the genre.

The results may not be what you'd expect. At the time of writing, last year's film by Seb Edwards featuring Elton John is sitting at the top of the heap, followed by all five of the ads directed by Dougal Wilson. We would expect the film that started it all – 'The Long Wait' – to be higher up the list, but that's showbiz!


1) John Lewis - Elton's Piano (2018)

The rumours around Elton John's involvement in this year's John Lewis Christmas ad were true then. The 71 year old superstar has lent his voice and his gravitas to the advertising's biggest event as it edges away from its well-established template into a slightly different shape. The film uses a Time's Arrow approach to Elton John's life, opening with a reflective moment on the piano and a glance through his stellar career.



RATE IT YOURSELF HERE



2) John Lewis - Monty the Penguin (2014)

A remarkable aspect of the John Lewis Christmas phenomenon is the way adam&eveDDB take the annual anticipation in their stride and make it work totally to the advantage of the brand. Fulfilling expectations after success is so difficult we even have a name for it - that "difficult second album syndrome" - but this Christmas institution is already onto its sixth album and there's no sense of any difficulty in maintaining the quality. Indeed, this year's may be the best yet.



RATE IT YOURSELF HERE



3) John Lewis - Buster the Boxer (2016)

As the world reels in revulsion at the decision to put Donald Trump in The White House, one wise Twitter user summed up the mood of the nation. Philip Westerman used the social media platform to say: "The John Lewis Christmas advert better be fucking spectacular". Well, we've got news for you, Mr Westerman... for the next two minutes, everything's going to be all right because it is "fucking spectacular".



RATE IT YOURSELF HERE



4) John Lewis - The Journey (2012)

An utterly lovely commercial for John Lewis to mark Christmas... again. Following last year's brilliance was always going to be difficult but it cannot be doubted that they've succeeded with this wonderfully involving tale of devotion. Doff your hats to Adam&EveDDB and Mr Dougal Wilson.



RATE IT YOURSELF HERE



5) John Lewis - The Long Wait (2011)

A young boy's wait for Christmas Day seems unending but, despite the soundtrack, his motives are neither selfish or materialistic. The twist is lovely and you may find yourself getting a little emotional as you watch him dash to give rather than receive. A beautiful film which captures the true spirit of Christmas.



RATE IT YOURSELF HERE



6) John Lewis & Waitrose - Excitable Edgar (2019)

The most eagerly-awaited commercial of the year has been released... the John Lewis Christmas ad - brought to you this year in association with their supermarket partners Waitrose. After last year's departure from the usual template, this ad is a return to the fold. For the fifth time, Dougal Wilson has been entrusted with the director's chair and for the fifth time he has delivered an exquisite tale sure to strike a chord with a public who genuinely anticipate this commercial with great excitement.



RATE IT YOURSELF HERE



7) John Lewis - The Bear and the Hare (2013)

John Lewis's Christmas effort is now well established as the 'daddy', and the clamour ahead of this year's unveiling has been quite remarkable. Is it worth all the fuss? Of course it is. Like last year, there's a notable absence of humans in the ad and this proves a wise choice as it allows an unremitting level of sentimentality.



RATE IT YOURSELF HERE



8) John Lewis - Man on the Moon (2015)

The anticipation ahead of the John Lewis Christmas commercial grows and grows and this year it's been so great that the backlash began before anyone had even seen it. Those silly naysayers have - as you might expect - just been completely trumped by the film itself which is unerringly beautiful.



RATE IT YOURSELF HERE



9) John Lewis - Moz the Monster (2017)

The template established by adam&eveDDB for John Lewis's big Christmas commercial undoubtedly makes it predictable. We could all anticipate that it will be a sweetly emotional film featuring a child in the build-up to Christmas Day but because it's a formula which the public adores, the most predictable aspect of all is the love it will receive.



RATE IT YOURSELF HERE



Stories

RÉMI LAUDAT JOINS ACADEMY

Academy have signed dancer-turned-director Remi Laudat to their roster for representation.


RIFF RAFF FILMS ENLIST PSYOP.

US animation studio Psyop have joined Riff Raff Films for representation in the UK and the Netherlands.


JOVAN TODOROVIC IS ANONYMOUS.

Anonymous Content have signed director Jovan Todorovic to their roster for representation.


76 LTD WELCOME SIMON HUNTER.

Filmmaker Simon Hunter will now direct commercials and branded content under the 76 Ltd banner.


MARTIN SCALI MEETS HENRY.

Paris-based production company Henry have completed the signing of director Martin Scali.


RUTH WARDELL JOINS OKAY STUDIO.

OKAY STUDIO have added colourist Ruth Wardell to their growing team.


KERI COLLINS IS PRESENCE AND CORRECT.

BAFTA-winning comedy director Keri Collins has joined Presence and expanded their already impressive roster.


MARLIES VAN DER WEL JOINS PARTIZAN STUDIO

Partizan Studio have signed award-winning Dutch filmmaker Marlies van der Wel to their roster for representation.


DARK ENERGY SWOOP FOR AXELLE COURLANDER.

Director and football fanatic Axelle Courlander has joined Dark Energy for commercial representation.


DIRECTOR ED MCCULLOCH SAYS HELLO LOVE.

Hello Love are eager to see what Utah’s Ed McCulloch can achieve on these shores after signing him for representation.


DAN DE WINTER IS AT WORK

Work have appointed New York-based editor Dan de Winter to their global roster.


AGENT ELSON TUNES INTO THIRD CHANNEL.

Story-driven content studio Third Channel have joined Agent Elson's stable for representation.


COFFEE & TV PROMOTE MARTIN ALLAN AND STEVE WAUGH.

Visual content studio Coffee & TV have confirmed Martin Allan and Steve Waugh as their new creative directors.


'THAT JAM' SIGN TO PARK VILLAGE

Park Village have signed 'That Jam' - a directorial partnership comprising Joe Beverley and Sam Hurlock.


OB MANAGEMENT WELCOME CORAL BROWN.

London-based director Coral Brown is the latest to join OB Management's roster of independent filmmakers.


CANISTER JOIN COMMON PEOPLE

Directing duo Canister have joined Common People Films for representation.


MARTIN KREJCI JOINS MERMAN.

Merman have completed the signing of Czech director Martin Krejci for commercial representation in the UK.


KFC GO FINGERLESS.

Covid-19 has changed almost everything about the way we live it seems… and that includes how we eat a bucket of fried chicken.


BETHAN SELLER TUNES INTO RADICALMEDIA.

RadicalMedia have completed the signing of commercials director Bethan Seller for global representation.


RUTH SEWELL JOINS DARK ENERGY

Dark Energy have added London-born director Ruth Sewell to their roster.


THE SWEETSHOP ENLIST KATE HALPIN.

The Sweetshop have signed filmmaker Kate Halpin for commercial representation in Australia.


JOHN O'HAGAN IS HUNGRY (MAN) FOR MORE.

Hungry Man alumnus John O'Hagan has rejoined the company for global representation.


HAVE YOUR VOICE HEARD BY CONTRIBUTING TO THIS SURVEY OF PRODUCERS.

Producers from across the UK advertising industry are being asked to contribute to a survey set up by Presence's Danny Fleet.


COMMON PEOPLE FILMS SIGN CATHERINE LOSING.

Director and photographer Catherine Losing has joined the ranks at Common People Films.


THE SWEETSHOP NAB DERMOT MALONE

The Sweetshop have signed Irish director Dermot Malone to their international roster.


Stories

David Reviews - Lovely Lenzie Ltd, Woodbourne House, Seven Sisters, Lenzie, G66 3AW. Telephone: +44 141 776 7766. Editor: Jason Stone.